Thursday, June 28, 2007
Too young
I spent several hours yesterday at the Walter Reed Army Medical Center in Washington DC. I was there for my own insignificant purposes but was graciously allowed the opportunity to spend several hours in the main lobby. While I was there I saw several (and by several I mean, probably 10-15 in the span of two hours) young men come through the lobby who had recently lost one or both of their legs. In a few cases the wounds were much worse and signs of burns and surgical procedures were visible on the face, hands and arms. If I had to guess I would say every one of them were under the age of 25. I discretely watched them pass by with curiosity and empathy. Some went through the lobby in wheel chairs others on cruches and some walked triumphantly on new high tech prosethetic legs. One thing they all had in common, they were too young to have to go through life like that. I wanted to ask them questions. Were they angry, were they proud, how did it happen, but I said nothing because I think I already know the answers to those questions. I can't help but feel bad for them but I'm overwhelmed at the sacrifices that they make.
Tuesday, June 26, 2007
Not Our War?
"War is an ugly thing, but not the ugliest of things. The decayed and degraded state of moral and patriotic feeling which thinks that nothing is worth war is much worse." John Stuart Mill
I hear many people say we need to get out of Iraq. A growing number say we shouldn't get caught up in the sectarian violence, the civil war, that is on going in Iraq. Good American soldiers are dying in a fight that isn't our war. People like to draw comparisons to history and to the Vietnam war. I would like to draw a comparison to World War II. A war that most see as a high point in Americana. But the war in Europe wasn't our war either. Americans weren't being targeted, and our country wasn't being invaded. The Japanese attacked Pearl Harbor in December 1941, reminiscent of the surprise attack on Sept 11th 60 years later, and in response, we declared war on Germany 3 days later. Why? Why didn't we divert our full attention to the Pacific Theater and let the Europeans deal with their own problems. Because America will always fight for liberty, security and stability. We will not sit idle and watch from the sidelines as people are oppressed by an invading enemy or a government, and most importantly, we have the will and capability to do so. The latter part is what sometimes distinguishes us from other countries, especially our European allies. But there is another important point that sometimes alludes the casual complainer who likes to throw out phrases like, "How come we don't invade Sudan to prevent the genocide(sectarian violence) there? or Rawanda, or Cambodia." Tell me what global security implication the genocide in those countries pose. When the Hutu's killed off the Tutsi's what global difference did it make. At the risk of sounding callous I ask, how does that effect us; and the short answer is that it doesn't. Maybe Thomas Friedman can draw me a globalization link between genocide in Rawanda and sales forcast of the Apple iPhone but I doubt it. Contrary to growing popluar belief America doesn't throw its youth at just any old war. There is a thought process. It is extremely satisfying to some to glom onto big oil companies as one possible conspiracy theory driving the American war machine. Surely Haliburton, with all their filthy rich contracts in Iraq and Afghanistan, is the reason young American boys and girls are losing their lives for this "lost cause". Not so fast. . .I would like to propose another possibility.
Maybe, just maybe, we actually do have intelligent, long-range strategic thinkers in the decision making positions of the United States government. What if the decision to go to war, to risk the lives of American military service men and women, is actually based upon the National Security of America. I believe it is. Iraq has approximately a quarter of the world's oil exports. What would the global economic impact, not to mention the devastating blow to the American economy, be if a rogue dictator, with nuclear weapons, or an unstable state ruled by a lawless terrorist organization, held Iraq's oil exports hostage. The ripple effects to the global economy could be devastating. Maybe that is why we choose to go to war in Iraq, or invade Normandy. Maybe, (spoken with sarcasm) not withstanding a foreign attack on our home soil (Pearl Harbor) we choose to go to war when the National Security of America, via the global economy, is threatened (Nazi Germany). I'm not suggesting that the United States doesn't cherish the life and liberty of those poor souls in places like Cambodia and Rawanda, other other countries like Sudan where battleing sectarian factions are committing horrific acts of genocide, but what I am suggesting is that before the United Sates commits it troops to something like that we first weigh the decsion against the potential National security implications. If the conflict doesn't pose a significant economic or domestic threat to our National security, then the chances of the US committing its troops is highly unrealistic. The US would rather pursue an alternative edn to the conflict through diplomacy and sanctions. That's just the cold hard facts. Can you imagine what the public outcry would be if the US was bogged down in Civil War in Sudan and we just topped 3500 US military casualties with no perceptible threat to our National security. There will still be those who continue to chant the mantra, "No blood for oil!" Some people just can't be reached; and in another forum, I will side with those who advocate alternative fuels and less reliance on foreign oil. I'm all for it and I think it makes sense, but we are not there yet. The fact is, The US economy, and the global economy, is dependent on foreign oil, a large majority of which comes from Iraq and the Persian Gulf. Therefore, our National Security is at stake.
So this leads us now to the next argument that Iraq wasn't the primary threat. In that, with the benefit of crystal clear hindsight, I will concede; but rewind back to 2001. American had just been hit hard. Saddam Hussein had defied UN Security Council Resolutions for the last 10 years and had successfully prevented UN weapons inspectors from full disclosure of the Iraq "Weapons" program. Forget that you now know that that weapons program never existed. Everyone, including the previous administration, was convinced that Iraq was close to developing a nuclear weapon. Bad intelligence I agree, but none the less, that is what we all believed. Enter 9/11 and the famous,"If you are not with us then you are against us" speech by the President. Who disagreed with that? How could you disagree with that at that time in our Nations history? I can not debate with someone who now has the benefit of hindsight. The fact remains that Iraq was percieved as a direct threat to our National security, and now, even with the benefit of hindsight, and our Soldiers and Marines are right in the middle of the fight, Iraq continues to be a direct threat to our National security, but for a whole different set of reasons. Now Iraq could potentially become a breeding ground for militant jihadist if we allow them to take root in an unstable country. A parasite needs a host to survive and that host becomes Iraq if we allow them to settle there. And yes the oil issue still remains. What about all those oil fields potentially under the control of a group like Al Qeada? And then, once you get past the increased terrorist threat to our country and our allies, and the threat to the global economy, come life and liberty of all those innocent Iraqis caught in this horriffic genocide of secatarian violence. Most of them just want a safe place to raise their children, and earn a living. So for them we fight. America loves liberty. We want people to enjoy the same freedom that we have here at home. America has a soft heart. We don't like violence and we especially find it hard to swallow even one American death on foreign soil. Somebody once said (I think it was Alexis de Tocqueville) that the only thing harder than starting a war for a democracy is ending one. We will always find it difficult to do what it takes to win a war because that means more risk to American lives.
If you had a checklist with all the conditions that must be met before going to war, Iraq checks all the blocks. Freedom for an oppressed people, direct threat to our National Security, direct threat to the Global Economy. This is our war and, like the historic struggle of World War II, where the domination of the globe by the forces of Nazi Germany were a tangible threat, we need to step up and meet it head on with swift, decisive and overwhelming violence, and realize that every precious life that is lost in Iraq, while unfortunate, is justified. We are on the moral high ground. Stop believing the lies that try to turn us in to the bad guy. The success in the fight cannot be measured by body counts and car bombs. It must be measured by ground gained, by neighborhoods secured, and the ability of the average Iraqi to go the the market without the fear of death. We are winning this war but you couldn't tell it from the newspapers. Stop believing that the more bombs that go off is any kind of indicator of success or failure in Iraq. We must finish this job, and we must win. Its not just the American reputation at stake, although it could be argued that this is a major issue, but our National security and the security of all peaceful nations. This is our war.
I hear many people say we need to get out of Iraq. A growing number say we shouldn't get caught up in the sectarian violence, the civil war, that is on going in Iraq. Good American soldiers are dying in a fight that isn't our war. People like to draw comparisons to history and to the Vietnam war. I would like to draw a comparison to World War II. A war that most see as a high point in Americana. But the war in Europe wasn't our war either. Americans weren't being targeted, and our country wasn't being invaded. The Japanese attacked Pearl Harbor in December 1941, reminiscent of the surprise attack on Sept 11th 60 years later, and in response, we declared war on Germany 3 days later. Why? Why didn't we divert our full attention to the Pacific Theater and let the Europeans deal with their own problems. Because America will always fight for liberty, security and stability. We will not sit idle and watch from the sidelines as people are oppressed by an invading enemy or a government, and most importantly, we have the will and capability to do so. The latter part is what sometimes distinguishes us from other countries, especially our European allies. But there is another important point that sometimes alludes the casual complainer who likes to throw out phrases like, "How come we don't invade Sudan to prevent the genocide(sectarian violence) there? or Rawanda, or Cambodia." Tell me what global security implication the genocide in those countries pose. When the Hutu's killed off the Tutsi's what global difference did it make. At the risk of sounding callous I ask, how does that effect us; and the short answer is that it doesn't. Maybe Thomas Friedman can draw me a globalization link between genocide in Rawanda and sales forcast of the Apple iPhone but I doubt it. Contrary to growing popluar belief America doesn't throw its youth at just any old war. There is a thought process. It is extremely satisfying to some to glom onto big oil companies as one possible conspiracy theory driving the American war machine. Surely Haliburton, with all their filthy rich contracts in Iraq and Afghanistan, is the reason young American boys and girls are losing their lives for this "lost cause". Not so fast. . .I would like to propose another possibility.
Maybe, just maybe, we actually do have intelligent, long-range strategic thinkers in the decision making positions of the United States government. What if the decision to go to war, to risk the lives of American military service men and women, is actually based upon the National Security of America. I believe it is. Iraq has approximately a quarter of the world's oil exports. What would the global economic impact, not to mention the devastating blow to the American economy, be if a rogue dictator, with nuclear weapons, or an unstable state ruled by a lawless terrorist organization, held Iraq's oil exports hostage. The ripple effects to the global economy could be devastating. Maybe that is why we choose to go to war in Iraq, or invade Normandy. Maybe, (spoken with sarcasm) not withstanding a foreign attack on our home soil (Pearl Harbor) we choose to go to war when the National Security of America, via the global economy, is threatened (Nazi Germany). I'm not suggesting that the United States doesn't cherish the life and liberty of those poor souls in places like Cambodia and Rawanda, other other countries like Sudan where battleing sectarian factions are committing horrific acts of genocide, but what I am suggesting is that before the United Sates commits it troops to something like that we first weigh the decsion against the potential National security implications. If the conflict doesn't pose a significant economic or domestic threat to our National security, then the chances of the US committing its troops is highly unrealistic. The US would rather pursue an alternative edn to the conflict through diplomacy and sanctions. That's just the cold hard facts. Can you imagine what the public outcry would be if the US was bogged down in Civil War in Sudan and we just topped 3500 US military casualties with no perceptible threat to our National security. There will still be those who continue to chant the mantra, "No blood for oil!" Some people just can't be reached; and in another forum, I will side with those who advocate alternative fuels and less reliance on foreign oil. I'm all for it and I think it makes sense, but we are not there yet. The fact is, The US economy, and the global economy, is dependent on foreign oil, a large majority of which comes from Iraq and the Persian Gulf. Therefore, our National Security is at stake.
So this leads us now to the next argument that Iraq wasn't the primary threat. In that, with the benefit of crystal clear hindsight, I will concede; but rewind back to 2001. American had just been hit hard. Saddam Hussein had defied UN Security Council Resolutions for the last 10 years and had successfully prevented UN weapons inspectors from full disclosure of the Iraq "Weapons" program. Forget that you now know that that weapons program never existed. Everyone, including the previous administration, was convinced that Iraq was close to developing a nuclear weapon. Bad intelligence I agree, but none the less, that is what we all believed. Enter 9/11 and the famous,"If you are not with us then you are against us" speech by the President. Who disagreed with that? How could you disagree with that at that time in our Nations history? I can not debate with someone who now has the benefit of hindsight. The fact remains that Iraq was percieved as a direct threat to our National security, and now, even with the benefit of hindsight, and our Soldiers and Marines are right in the middle of the fight, Iraq continues to be a direct threat to our National security, but for a whole different set of reasons. Now Iraq could potentially become a breeding ground for militant jihadist if we allow them to take root in an unstable country. A parasite needs a host to survive and that host becomes Iraq if we allow them to settle there. And yes the oil issue still remains. What about all those oil fields potentially under the control of a group like Al Qeada? And then, once you get past the increased terrorist threat to our country and our allies, and the threat to the global economy, come life and liberty of all those innocent Iraqis caught in this horriffic genocide of secatarian violence. Most of them just want a safe place to raise their children, and earn a living. So for them we fight. America loves liberty. We want people to enjoy the same freedom that we have here at home. America has a soft heart. We don't like violence and we especially find it hard to swallow even one American death on foreign soil. Somebody once said (I think it was Alexis de Tocqueville) that the only thing harder than starting a war for a democracy is ending one. We will always find it difficult to do what it takes to win a war because that means more risk to American lives.
If you had a checklist with all the conditions that must be met before going to war, Iraq checks all the blocks. Freedom for an oppressed people, direct threat to our National Security, direct threat to the Global Economy. This is our war and, like the historic struggle of World War II, where the domination of the globe by the forces of Nazi Germany were a tangible threat, we need to step up and meet it head on with swift, decisive and overwhelming violence, and realize that every precious life that is lost in Iraq, while unfortunate, is justified. We are on the moral high ground. Stop believing the lies that try to turn us in to the bad guy. The success in the fight cannot be measured by body counts and car bombs. It must be measured by ground gained, by neighborhoods secured, and the ability of the average Iraqi to go the the market without the fear of death. We are winning this war but you couldn't tell it from the newspapers. Stop believing that the more bombs that go off is any kind of indicator of success or failure in Iraq. We must finish this job, and we must win. Its not just the American reputation at stake, although it could be argued that this is a major issue, but our National security and the security of all peaceful nations. This is our war.
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)

