The rules murdering our troops
By RALPH PETERS
Last Updated: 2:55 AM, September 24, 2009
Posted: 12:57 AM, September 24, 2009
When enemy action kills our troops, it's unfortunate. When our own moral fecklessness murders those in uniform, it's unforgivable.
In Afghanistan, our leaders are complicit in the death of each soldier, Marine or Navy corpsman who falls because politically correct rules of engagement shield our enemies.
Mission-focused, but morally oblivious, Gen. Stan McChrystal conformed to the Obama Way of War by imposing rules of engagement that could have been concocted by Code Pink:
* Unless our troops in combat are absolutely certain that no civilians are present, they're denied artillery or air support.
* If any civilians appear where we meet the Taliban, our troops are to "break contact" -- to retreat.
These ROE are a cave-in to the Taliban's shameless propaganda campaign that claimed innocents were massacred every time our aircraft appeared overhead. (Afghan President Mohammed Karzai and our establishment media backed the terrorists.)
The Taliban's goal was to level the playing field -- to deny our troops their technological edge. Our enemies more than succeeded.
And what has our concern for the lives of Taliban sympathizers accomplished? The Taliban now make damned sure that civilians are present whenever they conduct an ambush or operation.
So they attack -- and we quit the fight, lugging our dead and wounded back to base.
We've been through this b.s. before. In Iraq, we wanted to show respect to our enemies, so the generals announced early on that we wouldn't enter mosques. The result? Hundreds of mosques became terrorist safe houses, bomb factories and weapons caches.
Why is this so hard to figure out? We tell our enemies we won't attack X. So they exploit X. Who wouldn't?
It isn't just that war is hell. It's that war must be hell, otherwise why would the enemy ever quit?
This week's rumblings from the White House suggest that we may, at last, see a revised strategy that concentrates on killing our deadliest enemies -- but I'll believe it when I see the rounds go down-range.
Meanwhile, our troops die because our leaders are moral cowards.
Over the decades, political correctness insinuated itself into the ranks of our "Washington player" generals and admirals. We now have four-stars who believe that improving our enemies' self-esteem is a crucial wartime goal.
And the Army published its disastrous Counterinsurgency Manual a few years back -- doctrine written by military intellectuals who, instead of listening to Infantry squad leaders, made a show of consulting "peace advocates" and "humanitarian workers."
The result was a manual based on a few heavily edited case studies "proving" that the key to success in fighting terrorists is to hand out soccer balls to worm-eaten children. The doctrine ignored the brutal lessons of 3,000 years of history -- because history isn't politically correct (it shows, relentlessly, that the only effective way to fight faith-fueled insurgents is with fire and sword).
The New York Times lavished praise on the manual. What does that tell you?
A few senior officers continue to push me to "lay off" the Counterinsurgency Manual. Sorry, but I'm more concerned about supporting the youngest private on patrol than I am with the reputation of any general.
As a real general put it a century ago, "The purpose of an Army is to fight." And the purpose of going to war is to win (that dirty word). It's not to sacrifice our own troops to make sad-sack do-gooders back home feel good.
We need to recognize that true morality lies in backing our troops, not in letting them die for whacko theories.
The next time you read about the death of a soldier or Marine in Afghanistan, don't just blame the Taliban. Blame the generals and politicians who sent them to war, then took away their weapons.
Ralph Peters' new novel is "The War After Armageddon."
Friday, September 25, 2009
Wednesday, September 23, 2009
Quotes That I Want to Remember
"Most of us, most of the time, live in blissful ignorance of what a small elite, heroic group of Americans are doing for us night and day. As we speak, all over the globe, American sailors and submariners and aviators are doing something very dangerous. People say, ‘Well, it can’t be too dangerous because there are no wrecks.’ But the reason we don’t have more accidents is that these are superb professionals; the fact that they master the dangers does not mean that dangers aren’t real.
Right now, somewhere around the world, young men and women are landing high-performance jet aircraft on the pitching decks of aircraft carriers–at night! You can’t pay people to do that; they do it out of love of country, of adventure, of the challenge. We all benefit from it, and the very fact that we don’t have to think about it tells you how superbly they are doing their job–living on the edge of danger so the rest of us need not think about, let alone experience danger."
George Will, ABC News
____________________________________
"War is an ugly thing, but not the ugliest of things. The decayed and degraded state of moral and patriotic feeling which thinks that nothing is worth war is much worse."
John Stuart Mill
________________________________________________________________
Beer is living proof that God loves us and wants us to be happy.
Benjamin Franklin
Right now, somewhere around the world, young men and women are landing high-performance jet aircraft on the pitching decks of aircraft carriers–at night! You can’t pay people to do that; they do it out of love of country, of adventure, of the challenge. We all benefit from it, and the very fact that we don’t have to think about it tells you how superbly they are doing their job–living on the edge of danger so the rest of us need not think about, let alone experience danger."
George Will, ABC News
____________________________________
"War is an ugly thing, but not the ugliest of things. The decayed and degraded state of moral and patriotic feeling which thinks that nothing is worth war is much worse."
John Stuart Mill
________________________________________________________________
Beer is living proof that God loves us and wants us to be happy.
Benjamin Franklin
Tuesday, September 22, 2009
Things that make you say. . .hmmmm.
The following list of statistics are just a few numbers that I run across and like to put down in writing. They are what they are. I don't necessarily have an agenda for these statistics, but I do think you can draw your own conclusions about things you hear in the news media and the hype surrounding certain events. For example, the horrible loss of US servicemen in Iraq pales in comparison to the loss of life on our roads in America. Just putting things perspective.
- In 17 years of combat in Vietnam, thats from 1957-1973, there were 58,209 US Service member deaths which include combat deaths plus casualties listed as other deaths. That is, on average, slightly higher than 3424 casualties per year and slightly higher than 9 casualites per day. These stats were taken from Wikipedia, but I checked several other websites that track similar statistics and they used approximately the same number the same number. archives.gov used 58,193. Only 16 different.
- From 2003 to September 2009, there were 4328 combat and other deaths in the Iraq War (globalsecurity.org list 4262) which equates to approximately 710 casualties per year over the last six years of combat in Iraq, which equates to an average of slightly below 2 casualties per day.
- Last year (2008) in the United States there were and estimated 37,313 motor vehicle fatalities as reported by the National Highway Traffic Safety Administration website. That is approximately 102 fatalities per day.
- Now here is a hard statistic to track down. This information comes from an April 2007 article on the everydayhealth.com website that focuses on health and medicine by Dr. Ed Zimney. I don't know who he is or where he got his statistics, but from the other websites that I visited including the Center for Disease control, they used similar statistics. In 2004 there were 29,569 handgun fatalities in the United States which includes 16,750 suicides. That equals 81 fatalities per day. But if your anything like me, you should probabably take out the 16,750 suicides because they were probably going to kill them self anyway with or with out a handgun. So if you take out the suicides you get 35 handgun fatalities per day in the US.
- As of September 13th, 2009, the World Health Organization websites says that world wide, the H1N1 (Swine Flu) has killed 3486 people in 2009, with almost 300,000 cases reported world wide. Sounds like a lot but actually a very small percentage of the worlds population of just over 6 and half Billion people.
- According to the CDC, in the United States from April 2009 to July 2009 (100 days), there were 43,771 cases of H1N1 flu virus reported. Of those cases, 302 people died (approximately 3 a day) from the swine flu or complications from the swine flu.
- The Center for Disease Control website states that every year in the United States 36,000 people die from the flu-or flu-related causes. WOW! That's the normal influenza, not the Swine Flu.
- Approximately 85% of Americans have health insurance. That equals to about 255 Million people if you go with the census bureau number of a 300 million US population.
- According to globalsecurity.org, there are 24,000 people that work in the Pentagon. I also saw estimates as high as 27,000. I worked there for 2 years in 2005 to 2007 and I can tell you that I have no idea what they all do.
- From the Bureau of Labor Statistics website there are 12,000 people that work for the State Department in the Washington DC area. There are also 20,000 people who work for the Department of Homeland Security just in Washington DC. Don't be misguided here, those departments are alot larger. These numbers are just for the Washington DC area. For example there are 149,000 people that work for the DHS nationwide.
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)

