Thursday, July 12, 2007

The Great American Melting Pot.

"We're all very different people. We're not Watusi, we're not Spartans, we're Americans. With a capital "A", huh? And you know what that means? Do you? That means that our forefathers were kicked out of every decent country in the world. We are the wretched refuse. We're the underdog. We're mutts." Bill Murry, Stripes, 1981


America is unique. Just catch a glimpse of a beauty pageant sometime and you might see an Asian-American girl win the title of Miss Hometown America and speak with a perfectly fluent Alabama accent. Ah! the American melting-pot. So what is all the hub-bub over the immigration issue? As I sit and ponder the solution to this vexing issue that has so grasped our country, I'm starting to convince myself that the issue isn't immigration but rather assimilation.



Correct me if I'm wrong, but we have laws, currently on the books, that delineates the process by which a foreigner can enter our country legally. Right? And, if a foreigner doesn't follow those laws and enters this country by "other means" then that person is an illegal alien and subject to criminal prosecution and deportation. Right? So the problem actually lies with the United Sates enforcing its own laws. There is no need to make new laws. We have a tendency to do that in America; spin our wheels setting up a new government agency or enacting new legislation when the agencies and the laws that we already have in place have the capacity to enforce the rules. Just because they are failing to do so is no reason to concoct a new law or create a new government agency. I think it makes politicians feel good to say they created a new government organization to oversee the . . blah. . .blah. . .blah.

Immigration isn't the problem. So what is the real problem? Most Americans recognize the fact that everyone in America, minus the native American Indian (which could be debated) has immigrated to this country at some point along their family tree. Most Americans have a soft spot for the foreigner who wants to come to American and start a new life. The pursuit of the American Dream is available to everyone. Let's narrow this down. I don't think most people have a problem with migrant workers coming to America looking for manual labor so that they can support their family back home (where ever that might be). There is a benefit to farmers being able to hire low cost laborers that don't require a health plan and a 401k. I, for one, like paying only a $1.29 for a head of lettuce. What American citizens don't like, I believe, is an illegal alien coming into this country (with their families), not paying taxes, using our health care system at the expense of the tax payer, getting their children into the public school system, having more children (at the expense of the tax payer) who automatically become legal American citizens, not learning the English language, and waving the Mexican flag at public events shouting "viva la Mexico!"

Did you see the recent United States Men's National soccer team play the Mexican National team in Chicago back in June. Even though this game was played in Chicago's Soldier Field it was definitely a hometown advantage for the Mexicans. I know that soccer is much more of a national sport in Mexico, but this was Chicago for goodness sake. I'm guessing that there were anywhere from 20 to 40 thousand people at the game and about 10-20 percent were United States fans and the other 80 to 90 percent were flag waving, painted face screaming Mexican fans. I maybe wrong on those numbers, I wasn't there in person. I watched the game from the comfort of my couch, but I couldn't help not noticing the overwhelming Mexican presence. By the way, the U.S. team won 2 to 1.

So this brings me to what I believe is the real, underlying problem with our current immigration issue, assimilation. For the most part, this our our own fault. We, the collective America, allow this to happen. America is going through this period of individual cultural recognition. We love to call people African Americans, or Mexican Americans or whatever. We have African American history Month and we teach Spanish immersion in our schools and we allow illegal aliens to come to America and not assimilate. Assimilation is what made the grand American experiment work. We don't have enclaves of groups of culturally distinct people at odds with their neighbors, ah la Quebec in Canada where the French population has been allowed to maintain their distinct cultural identity, speak French and time and again try to win a vote to separate from Canada to form their own Nation. Look a the former Yugoslavia. Pockets of distinct and very different cultures and languages and religions living in close proximity and the next thing you know you have a powder keg.

Without proof to offer, I believe that there is an concerted effort in our schools and in our media to normalize differences in cultural backgrounds and languages. We see it everyday, or at least those with school age children probably see it, but do we actually recognize the brainwashing when its happening. Through seemingly harmless and yet educational children's television programs, like Dora the Explorer and Go Diego Go, to name two, there is a full on effort to "teach" our children Spanish thru television. I use the word "teach" very tongue in cheek. What I really mean is that programs like these strive to normalize hispanic culture and language in our society and create an entire generation of our children who have become desensitized to the language differences. In short, our children are growing up thinking that it is perfectly normal not to speak English in America. The public schools do this as well through the never ending onslaught of cultural awareness programs and language immersion programs. It makes me wonder why an American public elementary school in San Diego,just miles across the border from Mexico, would have a Spanish Immersion program where the entire school is taught in Spanish

Yet we can't seem to see what is going on. It angers me to no end to have to press one on the phone in order to hear the instructions in English. There shouldn't be a choice. Language is the key issue here. Its is what makes us Americans. Look around you. Every public place you go, more and more signs are posted in Spanish. There are schools in American that don't even teach in English anymore. If you come to America from Mexico looking for work and you don't have to pay taxes or learn the language yet you get health care and you have your kids in school and they don't have to learn English in order to pass are you really in America or are you still in Mexico? You can't tell the difference and that is the big problem. You are Mexicans living in America instead of Americans.

"Every immigrant who comes here should be required within five years to learn English or leave the country." Theodore Roosevelt

I don't speak another language, but I wish that I did. If I had the time and patience I would learn Spanish, French, German, Arabic, Chinese. . . .I would learn as many languages as could. I like to be able to communicate with other people of other countries. I think it is vitally important in this age of globalization that children learn foreign languages in school. But don't misunderstand me. In America the language should be American English. You don't have to pass a law proclaiming English as the National Language, just stop allowing non-English speakers from getting away without ever having to learn our language. Foreign speakers should have to learn English in order to get through our education system. When you go to McDonald's the menu should only be in English. I don't want to place my order at the counter only to hear my order being repeated to the cook in Filipino. And this trend is going to be tough to reverse because our liberal education system has allowed this to happen. You can't just one day say, "English only spoken on the premises". That won't work. It has to start as soon as the person or family arrives in the country. It has to happen in the schools and in the communities. In San Diego, the Cinco De Mayo celebration is almost as big as the 4th of July. I'm not saying I don't enjoy going down town on Cinco de Mayo and enjoying half price Mexican cerveza. That's not the point. What we must be cautious of is this growing cultural separation where you have distinctive nationalistic cultures living in America. We should stop recognizing people based on their ethnic background. Mexican American, African American. . . .We are all Americans and if we don't start acting that way the very fabric of the American melting pot may begin to unravel.

Everyone should be proud of their heritage. Everyone should speak a foreign language. And every American citizen should know the words to the pledge of allegiance or the Star Spangled Banner in English. There are alot of problems with our immigration system but building a wall between your neighbors is not a good way to make friends. Migrant workers serve a purpose in America. There is obviously a need for the work. I believe we should develop a process where foreigners can come to America to work and send their money back to their families at home (or whatever they want to do with it) and we can document them and they get a worker pass to come and go. And if they want to use our health care system then they have to pay into the state and federal tax system and pay for some kind of limited health coverage plan. And if they want to send their kids to our schools then they will be required to become an American tax paying citizen with a United States address. But, if the person doesn't want to do all those things to take advantage of the benefits of living in America and they come here anyway and they don't follow the rules to be a documented worker, then they are breaking the law and we should have ridiculous fines for the employers and potential jail time for repeat offenses and the illegal alien should be rounded up and deported back to their country at the expense of their own country (not ours). If their country isn't willing to pay the deportation fees then America pays for it, but writes it down in a ledger and keeps track of how much that country owes us for deportation fees and the next time that country asks us for money through economic or military programs we say, first pay us what you owe us and then we'll help out your floundering economy. It doesn't sound that hard or confusing. We just need to start enforcing the law and use some common sense.

Here are some great, eye opening opinion articles on this same subject:

http://news.yahoo.com/s/uc/20070906/cm_uc_crpbux/op_333745

http://news.yahoo.com/s/ucac/20070822/cm_ucac/1down11999999togo

No comments: